Introduction
Choosing a laundry detergent that is both gentle on delicate skin and effective on stains is a critical decision for families with infants or members who suffer from eczema. This article compares two popular Amazon offerings: all Baby Liquid Laundry Detergent and Arm & Hammer Sensitive Skin Detergent. Both claim hypoallergenic, dye‑free formulas, yet they differ in concentration, price, load capacity and environmental credentials. By examining real product data and authentic customer sentiment, readers can determine which product aligns best with their laundry priorities.
Individual Product Overviews
all Baby Liquid Laundry Detergent
Brand: all Store
Price: $19.99
Rating: 4.7/5.0 from 5,563 reviews
Capacity: 75 oz bottle delivering up to 100 loads
Key strengths include pediatrician testing, Safer Choice certification, biodegradable surfactants and a light, non‑overpowering scent. The formula is concentrated, providing more cleaning power per drop than the previous 1.5 oz dose. It is safe for HE machines and works in cold water.
Customer quote: "Absolutely love this baby laundry detergent! It is gentle, effective, and leaves clothes smelling fresh without being overly perfumed."
Arm & Hammer Sensitive Skin Detergent
Brand: Arm & Hammer Store
Price: $13.98
Rating: 4.7/5.0 from 61,311 reviews
Capacity: 170 fl oz bottle delivering up to 170 medium loads
Key strengths include dermatologist‑tested, SkinSAFE certification, 2× stain‑fighter concentration, and the inclusion of baking soda for odor control. The detergent is free‑clear, containing no dyes, perfumes or preservatives, and works in both standard and HE machines.
Customer quote: "It washes beautifully and is completely scent‑free, which we really appreciate. It works well for our family, especially those with eczema."
Head‑to‑Head Comparison
Price and Value
- all Baby costs $19.99 for 100 loads, equating to $0.20 per load.
- Arm & Hammer costs $13.98 for 170 loads, equating to $0.08 per load.
While all Baby is more expensive per load, its Safer Choice certification and pediatrician testing may justify the premium for parents prioritising the highest safety standards.
Features and Specifications
| Feature | all Baby | Arm & Hammer |
|---|---|---|
| Load Capacity | 100 loads (75 oz) | 170 loads (170 fl oz) |
| Concentration | More cleaning power per drop vs previous 1.5 oz dose | 2× stain‑fighter power vs leading value detergent |
| Skin Certification | Safer Choice (EPA) | SkinSAFE 100% certified |
| Fragrance | Lightly scented | Scent‑free |
| Surfactants | Biodegradable, phosphate‑free | Includes baking soda, low‑sudsing |
| Machine Compatibility | All machines, including HE | Standard and HE machines |
Customer Ratings and Feedback
Both products share a rating of 4.7 out of 5, yet the volume of reviews differs dramatically. Arm & Hammer boasts 61,311 reviews, indicating a larger user base and broader market penetration. all Baby’s 5,563 reviews are fewer but highly focused on infant‑specific concerns such as rash prevention and gentle scent.
Performance and Reliability
Real‑world feedback highlights that all Baby excels at removing spit‑up stains and maintaining softness without leaving residue. Users repeatedly mention the concentration as a cost‑saving advantage. Arm & Hammer is praised for its powerful stain removal on muddy sports uniforms and its ability to neutralise odors thanks to baking soda. Both detergents function effectively in cold water, a key factor for energy‑conscious households.
Best Use Cases
- all Baby: Ideal for newborns, infants and toddlers with highly sensitive skin, as well as for parents who value EPA Safer Choice certification.
- Arm & Hammer: Suited for larger families, active individuals with frequent heavy stains, and users who prefer a completely scent‑free formula.
Pros & Cons
all Baby Liquid Laundry Detergent
- Pros: Pediatrician‑tested, Safer Choice certified, biodegradable, concentrated (100 loads), gentle scent, effective in cold water.
- Cons: Higher cost per load, limited to 100 loads, fragrance may still be perceptible to extremely scent‑sensitive users.
Arm & Hammer Sensitive Skin Detergent
- Pros: Lowest cost per load, 170‑load capacity, 2× stain‑fighter concentration, completely fragrance‑free, SkinSAFE certified, includes odor‑neutralising baking soda.
- Cons: No fragrance at all may be perceived as “plain” by users who prefer a fresh scent, larger bottle may be less convenient for small households.
Recommendations
For parents seeking a detergent that has been specifically tested for infant skin and carries EPA Safer Choice endorsement, all Baby Liquid Laundry Detergent is the recommended choice. It provides gentle cleaning power, a light scent and a concentration that stretches to 100 loads.
For households that prioritize cost efficiency, high load capacity, and a completely scent‑free experience, especially when dealing with heavy outdoor stains, Arm & Hammer Sensitive Skin Detergent offers the best overall value.
FAQ
- Is either detergent safe for use in high‑efficiency (HE) washers?
- Yes. Both all Baby and Arm & Hammer are formulated to be low‑sudsing and safe for HE machines.
- Can these detergents be used for adult clothing?
- Absolutely. While all Baby is marketed for babies, its hypoallergenic formula works well on adult garments, especially for users with sensitive skin. Arm & Hammer’s strong stain‑fighting power makes it suitable for all ages.
- Do they contain phosphates?
- Neither product contains phosphates. all Baby explicitly states “no phosphates,” and Arm & Hammer’s formula is phosphate‑free as well.
- How do they perform in cold water?
- Both detergents are designed to work effectively in cold water, helping reduce energy consumption without sacrificing cleaning performance.
- Are the surfactants biodegradable?
- all Baby uses biodegradable surfactants. Arm & Hammer does not explicitly claim biodegradability, but its formula is low‑impact and includes natural baking soda.
Conclusion
Both detergents deliver high ratings and meet the core requirement of being gentle on sensitive skin. The decision hinges on specific priorities: if safety certifications, infant‑focused testing and a light scent are paramount, all Baby provides a premium, concentrated solution at $0.20 per load. If cost per load, maximum capacity and a completely fragrance‑free experience are more important, Arm & Hammer offers superior value at $0.08 per load while still delivering strong stain removal. Ultimately, families with newborns may favour all Baby, whereas larger households or active individuals will likely benefit from Arm & Hammer.
Products Mentioned in This Review
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the key differences between all Baby Liquid Laundry Detergent and Arm & Hammer Sensitive Skin Detergent?
All Baby is a concentrated, pediatrician‑tested formula with Safer Choice certification, while Arm & Hammer is an enzyme‑free detergent that emphasizes a larger bottle size and lower price per load.
Is all Baby Liquid Laundry Detergent safe for babies and adults with eczema?
Yes, it is hypoallergenic, dye‑free and has been pediatrician‑tested, making it suitable for sensitive skin and eczema sufferers.
How many laundry loads does each detergent provide?
The 75 oz all Baby bottle yields about 100 loads, whereas the Arm & Hammer bottle typically offers around 150 loads depending on the size purchased.
Do these detergents have eco‑friendly credentials?
All Baby uses biodegradable surfactants and holds Safer Choice certification; Arm & Hammer highlights its enzyme‑free formula but does not carry a specific eco‑label.
Which product gives better value for money?
Arm & Hammer generally costs less per load, but all Baby may be worth the premium for families prioritizing pediatrician testing and certified safety.